Data Underlying the Publication: Envisioning Contestability Loops
doi: 10.4121/8eb71eb5-cc7f-4055-aba3-2e90812a940b
- Government and Politics
- Artificial Intelligence and Image Processing
- Design Practice and Management
- Applied Ethics
- Policy and Administration
- Transport
- Philosophy and Religious Studies
- Built Environment and Design
- Technology
- Information and Computing Sciences
- Studies in Human Society
- Law, Politics and Community Services
CC BY 4.0
,
Ianus Keller
,
Mireia Yurrita Semperena
,
Denis Bulygin
,
Gerd Kortuem
,
Neelke Doorn
Data underlying the publication "Envisioning Contestability Loops: Evaluating the Agonistic Arena as a Generative Metaphor for Public AI."
In this study, we seek to make explicit the guiding ideas underpinning contestable AI research. We construct the generative metaphor of the Agonistic Arena from the political theory of agonistic pluralism. We combine this metaphor and current contestable AI guidelines into an infographic supporting the early-stage concept design of public AI system contestability mechanisms. We evaluate this infographic in five workshops paired with focus groups with a total of 18 practitioners, yielding ten concept designs. Our findings describe mechanisms for contestability proposed by these concept designs. Building on these findings, we subsequently evaluate the efficacy of the Agonistic Arena as a generative metaphor for the design of public AI and identify two competing metaphors at play in this space: the Black Box and the Sovereign.
The TU Delft Human Research Ethics Committee approved this study.
The data consists of:
- Scans of concept design sketches made by workshop participants (PDF)
- Transcripts of audio recordings of participants' verbal descriptions of their concept designs (TXT)
- Workshop schedule (PDF)
- Concept design summaries (PDF)
- Creative brief (PDF)
- Focus group guide (PDF)
- Workshop schedule (PDF)
- 2024-06-18 first online, published, posted
- BRIdging Data in the built Environment (BRIDE) (grant code CISC.CC.018) [more info...] Dutch Research Council
DATA
- 511,165 bytesMD5:
0ab0c1841c202bca75c6ddeb94c3b296case-description.pdf - 42,943,197 bytesMD5:
ca1f7f41df20f37e7986aeace1fb6f8aconcept-design-summaries.pdf - 3,772,809 bytesMD5:
b5dfa5a0cc3245eb091247bd10b2fba4creative-brief.pdf - 1,960,609 bytesMD5:
6a262940692325fc29ce3818f24f818cecl-concept-design-sketches-workshop-1.pdf - 774,088 bytesMD5:
e48c95645feb8f7a9ae8f1dc452c1aadecl-concept-design-sketches-workshop-2.pdf - 797,929 bytesMD5:
bb114a888809f9bc23808fd357f3ab5decl-concept-design-sketches-workshop-3.pdf - 2,519,043 bytesMD5:
5196cad5dbfafc1d34e0d793251982dcecl-concept-design-sketches-workshop-4.pdf - 2,408,068 bytesMD5:
cfe9caee9a26ebd0533d570785c09b04ecl-concept-design-sketches-workshop-5.pdf - 4,306 bytesMD5:
1a9d20ed113957d78dcad413cbad3a3cecl-raw-concept-description-workshop-1-1.txt - 3,782 bytesMD5:
2fdbdc7305dd9e842b92479ddfa78027ecl-raw-concept-description-workshop-1-2.txt - 3,601 bytesMD5:
e2d3579df88058b75d47c95cead2e1d6ecl-raw-concept-description-workshop-1-3.txt - 1,954 bytesMD5:
e8b37a97b7b953176e3c007eef5b1e60ecl-raw-concept-description-workshop-2.txt - 17,378 bytesMD5:
97046b55b6a8d2887b54c5a75e66674fecl-raw-concept-description-workshop-3.txt - 2,099 bytesMD5:
222f88a4b44796c51fae1a3e47fd245decl-raw-concept-description-workshop-4-1.txt - 6,445 bytesMD5:
cb063fabeb10720d58042c1271009ce2ecl-raw-concept-description-workshop-4-2.txt - 3,317 bytesMD5:
b847942762436dea8c47edc8d3cf1458ecl-raw-concept-description-workshop-4-3.txt - 5,003 bytesMD5:
4b5aedef5c9cedc485617674694beb88ecl-raw-concept-description-workshop-5-1.txt - 4,576 bytesMD5:
997502205256c562e4f91d9b67e087c9ecl-raw-concept-description-workshop-5-2.txt - 62,533 bytesMD5:
f56ae4baf9ab280555ecb1c70a914a02focus-group-guide.pdf - 54,725 bytesMD5:
efb25a539ed2f7188876ae64dc1fb3dfworkshop-schedule.pdf -
download all files (zip)
55,856,627 bytes unzipped
